Many years ago, I created a fake Yahoo email address in
order to play a practical joke on a colleague.
While it was all in good fun then, many
journals are now finding the prank is on them.
Authors, and in some cases editors, found a way to circumvent the
traditional peer-review system by supplying fake email addresses for
recommended reviewers, allowing them to review the paper themselves. Not
surprisingly, these “reviewers” returned glowing evaluations in record
time.
A spate of retractions highlights
the problem of fake “reviewers” that has plagued the scientific peer-review
system:
http://retractionwatch.com/2015/08/19/17-retractions-from-sage-journals-bring-total-fake-peer-review-count-to-250/
Fraudulent peer-review, whether perpetrated by authors,
editors or journals, undermines the hard work of the scientific community and
tarnishes the reputation of the entire biomedical research enterprise in the
eyes of the public. The Editors at
AJP-Lung are committed to providing peer review of the highest quality. When selecting reviewers for manuscripts, we utilize
a series of safeguards to ensure the validity of the process. Editors assign
reviewers from: 1) their own wide network of colleagues within the field; 2) the
Editorial Board, members of which undergo rigorous vetting by the Editors and journal
staff prior to appointment; and 3) the large APS reviewer database, which
provides verified contact information as well as links to each reviewer’s
publications. In cases where authors recommend
reviewers that are not already known to the editor, the recommended reviewer is
carefully scrutinized before being added to the potential reviewer list, typically
involving verification of institution and email address and a Pubmed search to
guarantee appropriate expertise and prevent conflict of interest.
Fair peer review requires trust on the part of all involved
parties. At AJP-Lung, we promise to
remain vigilant in securing the most qualified reviewers for your manuscripts.
-Larissa Shimoda, Associate Editor
-Wolfgang Kuebler, Associate Editor